Author: Peter Fendrich
Date: 14:46:56 02/17/05
Go up one level in this thread
On February 17, 2005 at 14:03:30, Tord Romstad wrote: >A couple of days ago, a well-known programmer and regular >poster here on the CCC claimed that a good opening book >was worth at least 700 Elo points. I thought this number >looked completely outrageous, and decided to do a simple >experiment. > >I am the author of a basic and minimalistic UCI chess engine >called Glaurung. Source code and executables for Mac OS X, >Linux and Windows can be found at the following URL: > >http://www.math.uio.no/~romstad/glaurung/glaurung.html > >Recently, I have played some test matches with Glaurung >against the strongest engine I have on my compter: Hiarcs >9.6. Not surprisingly, all such matches end in crushing >victories for Hiarcs. The last match I played ended >75-25 in Hiarcs' favor. > >As a crude test of the "good book=700 Elo" claim, I have >now repeated the match with identical program versions >and conditions, except that Hiarcs was now playing without >an opening book. Assuming that Hiarcs' book is worth 700 >Elo, the expected result of this second match would be >something like 95-5 in _Glaurung's_ favor. > >The actual result of the second match was very close to >the first match: Hiarcs won by 72-28. > >As far as I can see, this means that at least one of the >following must be true: > >a) The statement "good book=700 Elo" is lightyears away >from the truth. > >b) Hiarcs has an extremely bad opening book, and with a >half decent opening book it would be several hundred >rating points ahead of Shredder. > > >Tord Hi Tord, just to be complete: c) Something is wrong with your setup. For instance it could be some extreme result just with Hiarcs vs Glaurung N.B I didn't say it is but that's still one possibility... I dont' believe in the 700 difference anyway but it should at least mean something to get the extra time earned from the book moves. /Peter
This page took 0.01 seconds to execute
Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700
Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.