Computer Chess Club Archives

Search

Terms

Messages

Subject: Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy

Author: Gian-Carlo Pascutto

Date: 07:15:16 12/09/03

On December 09, 2003 at 10:01:15, Robert Hyatt wrote:

>However, the ICCA / ICGA rules to _not_ differentiate between the GUI and
>the engine.  The rules only address "the computer chess player".
>
>The decision was bogus.

They considered the situation and judged that playing on was an acceptable
decision. It wasn't even appealed.

How can it be bogus? What's the actual rule you're quoting here? Is it not
acceptable to deviate from them when there are good reasons to do so?

Maybe precedent is different, that doesn't make this decision invalid. Consider
each situation on its own merits, and that was done here.

--
GCP

Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Robert Hyatt 07:59:14 12/09/03
- Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Gian-Carlo Pascutto 11:26:47 12/09/03
  - Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Nicholas Cooper 19:38:45 12/09/03
    - Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Terry McCracken 20:20:15 12/09/03
      - Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Robert Hyatt 20:26:32 12/09/03
        
        Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Terry McCracken 21:11:47 12/09/03
        
        Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Robert Hyatt 21:19:06 12/09/03
  - Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Robert Hyatt 17:13:47 12/09/03
  - Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Amir Ban 14:49:59 12/09/03
    - Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Frank Phillips 10:03:04 12/10/03
    - Another example :) Gian-Carlo Pascutto 01:19:34 12/10/03
      - Re: Another example :) Tony Werten 06:56:01 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Robert Hyatt 15:19:25 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Tony Werten 00:45:01 12/11/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Robert Hyatt 06:41:40 12/11/03
      - Re: Another example :) Robert Hyatt 06:19:15 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Gian-Carlo Pascutto 06:23:38 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Robert Hyatt 07:14:18 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Amir Ban 14:41:49 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Matthew Hull 22:29:28 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Robert Hyatt 10:43:08 12/11/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Robert Hyatt 15:20:48 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Amir Ban 15:40:02 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Robert Hyatt 15:56:58 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Amir Ban 03:29:59 12/11/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Robert Hyatt 06:44:32 12/11/03
        
        (more) Robert Hyatt 15:26:04 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Bob Durrett 06:31:37 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Gian-Carlo Pascutto 06:34:49 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Uri Blass 06:41:49 12/10/03
      - Re: Another example :) Amir Ban 02:20:05 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example :) Bob Durrett 06:30:19 12/10/03
    - Another example of things that could happen Gian-Carlo Pascutto 01:03:23 12/10/03
      - Re: Another example of things that could happen Robert Hyatt 06:22:56 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Gian-Carlo Pascutto 06:27:56 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Robert Hyatt 07:13:00 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Uri Blass 06:59:44 12/10/03
      - Re: Another example of things that could happen Omid David Tabibi 03:55:35 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Gian-Carlo Pascutto 04:02:14 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Omid David Tabibi 13:09:34 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Robert Hyatt 14:55:54 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Omid David Tabibi 15:23:44 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Robert Hyatt 15:58:19 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Robert Hyatt 06:25:54 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Gian-Carlo Pascutto 06:30:36 12/10/03
        
        Re: Another example of things that could happen Robert Hyatt 07:09:03 12/10/03
  - Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Omid David Tabibi 11:52:28 12/09/03
    - Re: Shredder wins in Graz after controversy Robert Hyatt 17:15:34 12/09/03

This page took 0.02 seconds to execute

Last modified: Thu, 15 Apr 21 08:11:13 -0700

Current Computer Chess Club Forums at Talkchess. This site by Sean Mintz.